Impact of nasal surgery and turbinate reduction on mucosal temperature and cooling



The mucosal temperature postop has been shown to increase by average 0.9C (+3.0%) on both nasal expiration and inspiration, with the T°C difference between the nasal expiration and nasal inspiration being a constant 4C both preop and postop. This finding was true for all intranasa compartments: internal nasal valve, nasal cavity and inferior turbinate (Seresirikachorn 2024).

An ENS patient who is a member of the ENS fb group, has previously undergone both an aggressive turbinate reduction and aggressive septoplasty. He performed his own T°C measurements of the internal nasal valve (INV), using FLIR One Gen 3 thermal camera similar to the one used in Seresirikachorn 2024 study. His study showed that, on mouth breathing, there was a significant leak of air from the nose and that placing intranasal cotton plugs helped both reduce that air leak by about 60% and lower intranasal temperature by about 4%, with the difference between inhalation and exhalation being a constant 4.5C both with cotton and without. On nasal inhalation, this ENS patient used cotton plugs to effectively lower the intranasal T°C by about 0.6C (2.1%). However the exhalatory intranasal T°C stayed at 33.3C despite the cotton placement.

Seresirikachorn 2024 set the preoperative normal T°C for INV at 31.50C on nasal exhalation and 27.7C on nasal inhalation. This ENS patient with nasal cotton plugs in place, experienced 33.3C on nasal exhalation and 26.5C on nasal inhalation. While cotton plugs helped lower inhalationary T°C, they seemed ineffective with exhalatory T°C, leading to chronically high and damaging T°C on nasal exhalation, in absence of normal mucosal function and secretions. While +3-4% intranasal T°C increase may seem insignificant, that T°C increase appears to be detrimental to the histological structures of nasal mucosa, including cilia, ciliated cells, respiratory epithelium, goblet cells and basal cells. High Intranasal T°C leads to more mucosal dryness and atrophy, overheating of nasal cavities, septal burning, trigeminal pain and, ultimately, respiratory distress. Though there is no permanent solution to the destructive overheating of the nasal cavities from ENS, some patients find some relief in breathing clean cold air and/or refrigerator cooled supplemental oxygen. This shows again that nasal airflow resistance and intact mucosa are critical for adequate cooling of the nasal cavities and adjacent parts of the nervous system (e.g. ganglion block) and possibly even frontal parts of the brain.


Humidification of Lungs and Nasal Mucosa via water/vapor recycling in the nasal cavities


The nose provides 60-70% of total air humidification for the lungs, including 15% from inferior turbinates (Naftali 2005). On expiration, as air passes through the nose, it gives up heat to the cooler nasal mucosa. This cooling causes water vapor condensation and 33% return of both heat and moisture to the mucosal surfaces (White 2015). The sensation of pharyngeal dryness often reported by ENS patients is due to an airflow that is insufficiently humidified obviously yielding a drying of the airway mucosa (Scheithauer 2010). Intranasal dryness triggers the mucosal degradation and atrophy that leads to deterioration of the ENS condition and, ultimately, death. Additionally, dryness in the lungs leads to formation of more alveoli dead space, further hindering proper gas exchanges in the lungs.

The Tragic Impact of Empty Nose Syndrome (ENS): A story that ended in..

My Husband’s Unexpected ENS Diagnosis After Surgery

My husband underwent a septoplasty and turbinate reduction at the beginning of the summer. (we dont´t know when) He was never informed beforehand that a turbinate reduction would be performed it was never mentioned in his pre-op consultation (it's often like this). Before the surgery, he was a happy, healthy man. The PDF file for this case can be viewed or downloaded here
 

Immediate Symptoms: Sleep Deprivation and Nerve Damage

He immediately knew something was wrong after the procedure. He couldn’t sleep for more than a few minutes at a time, even with prescription sleeping aids. The sleep deprivation was beyond anything I thought a human could endure. His surgeon refused to take his calls. Desperate, we sought another ENT, a senior specialist at a major hospital, who diagnosed him with Empty Nose Syndrome (ENS) due to severe nerve damage. He couldn’t even feel a scope until it reached his throat.

The Devastating Outcome: Losing the Battle Against ENS
He couldn’t take it anymore, and earlier this month, he took his own life. (likely year 2022)

The Financial and Legal Aftermath of ENS Malpractice
Amidst my overwhelming grief, I also fear the financial consequences of his loss, especially since we have a one-year-old child. I haven’t spoken to any lawyers yet, and I’m not optimistic, but I wonder if anyone knows about malpractice lawsuits related to ENS. Has anyone ever succeeded in taking legal action against a surgeon?

A Warning to Others Considering Turbinectomy
For anyone considering a turbinectomy, please be extremely careful. My husband lost the life he worked so hard for, I lost my amazing partner, and our daughter lost her father.

The Medical Denial of Empty Nose Syndrome
The most tragic and infuriating part is the medical denial. We were fortunate to find two ENTs who at least acknowledged ENS, providing one provisional and one confident diagnosis. But his original surgeon, along with others we contacted, claimed they had "never heard of it." While I generally trust medical professionals, this level of denial borders on negligence—if not outright malice.

The Difficulty of Winning ENS Malpractice Cases
I have since learned that ENS malpractice cases are difficult to win. Unless there is gross negligence, success is rare. Some have managed to win cases, particularly those involving a total turbinectomy, which is considered an outdated method. But for those who had more conservative procedures, legal action seems nearly impossible.

Finding Support: The ENS Awareness Community
For support, I was advised to check the ‘Empty Nose Syndrome Awareness’ group on Facebook, where some have shared success stories regarding legal cases, while others have not been as fortunate.

Raising Awareness: The Unacknowledged Tragedy of ENS

This condition has stolen so many innocent lives, yet there is barely any acknowledgment of the doctors responsible. It is a tragedy that needs to be addressed. Link to the post on Reddit, click here or on the image below.





Psychologische Folgen der Nasenmuschel-OP – Forschung zu Empty Nose Syndrome













German: Unten finden Sie Zitate aus 16 Forschungsstudien, die die psychologische Belastung des Empty Nose Syndrome hervorheben. Die meisten Zitate enthalten interne Hyperlinks, die Sie direkt zur entsprechenden Studie führen, in der der Text erscheint (weiter unten in der PDF-Datei). Zudem gibt es Links, über die Sie die vollständigen Studien online finden können. Laden Sie hier die englische Version herunter oder sehen Sie sie sich an, oder warten Sie, bis die eingebettete Datei unten geladen wird (dies dauert etwa eine Minute). Am unteren Rand der eingebetteten Datei können Sie die Anzeigegröße des Dokuments anpassen.

Es gibt auch eine deutsche Version dieses Dokuments, die Sie hier ansehen oder herunterladen können.

English: Below, you will find quotes from 16 research studies highlighting the psychological burden of Empty Nose Syndrome. Most of the quotes have internal hyperlinks that will take you directly to the relevant study where the text appears (further down in the PDF file). There are also links where you can find the full studies online. Download or view the English version here or wait for the embedded file below to launch (it takes 1 min) You can change the display size of the document at the bottom of the embedded file. 

There is also a German version of this document that can be viewed or downloaded here.